Loading crypto prices…
Loan Rates

Secured vs. Unsecured Personal Loans: Key Differences

What collateral means, how secured and unsecured personal loans differ in rates, approval and risk, the common types of each and how to decide which fits your credit and your situation.

Car keys and a passbook as collateral next to a secured loan agreement, illustrating secured vs unsecured loans

Listen to this article5 min · AI voice

0:00 / 5:27

Key takeaways

  • A secured loan is backed by something you own, such as a savings account, CD, car or home. If you default, the lender can take it.
  • An unsecured loan relies only on your credit and income. If you default, the lender can sue and send the debt to collections, but has no claim on a specific asset.
  • Collateral usually means lower rates and easier approval, which helps borrowers with limited or damaged credit.
  • Never pledge collateral you cannot afford to lose, especially your home or the car you need to get to work.

Every loan is a bet by the lender that you will repay. With an unsecured loan, the bet rests on your credit history and income. With a secured loan, the lender also has a backup: an asset it can claim if you stop paying. That backup changes the price, the approval odds and, most importantly, what is at stake for you.

Secured vs. unsecured at a glance

Secured loanUnsecured loan
CollateralRequired: savings, CD, vehicle, home or other assetNone
Typical ratesLower, sometimes much lowerHigher; depend heavily on credit score
ApprovalEasier with fair or thin creditHarder with weak credit
AmountLimited by the value of the collateralLimited by credit and income
If you defaultLender can take the collateral, plus credit damageCollections, possible lawsuit and wage garnishment, plus credit damage
SpeedCan be slower if the asset must be valuedOften funded in one to a few days

Common types of secured loans

  • Share-secured or CD-secured loans: offered mainly by credit unions and some banks. Your savings are frozen as collateral, and the rate is often a few percentage points above what the savings earn. They are among the cheapest ways to borrow and a common tool for building credit.
  • Auto loans: the car secures the loan; the lender holds the title until you pay it off. Rates by credit tier are in auto loan rates by credit score.
  • Home equity loans and HELOCs: secured by your home, with rates far below personal loans, but your house is at stake; compare them in HELOC vs. home equity loan.
  • Secured personal loans backed by a vehicle you already own, offered by some online lenders and credit unions.
  • Secured credit cards: a cash deposit sets the credit line; a starting point for rebuilding credit, covered in best credit cards for bad credit.

Auto title loans and pawn loans are also secured, but they typically carry very high costs and short terms. Many states restrict them, and they put the asset at high risk.

Common types of unsecured loans

  • Personal loans from banks, credit unions and online lenders; current pricing is in average personal loan rates.
  • Credit cards, a revolving form of unsecured credit.
  • Most private and federal student loans.
  • Payday alternative loans from federal credit unions, capped at 28% interest; see payday alternative loans.

Why collateral lowers your rate

Lenders price loans by expected loss. With collateral, a default costs the lender less because it can recover part of the money, so it can charge less and accept borrowers it would otherwise decline. The effect is largest for borrowers with fair or poor credit, who might be quoted rates near 36% on an unsecured loan but much lower on a loan secured by savings. For borrowers with excellent credit, the gap is smaller and an unsecured loan is often good enough. How personal loan rates work explains the other factors.

Risks of each

Secured loans

  • You can lose the asset. With a car, that can also cost you your way to work.
  • Some secured loans include fees for valuations, liens or insurance on the collateral.
  • Borrowing against home equity converts consumer debt into debt that can lead to foreclosure.

Unsecured loans

  • Higher rates and origination fees, especially with weaker credit.
  • Default leads to collections, a large credit score drop and possibly a court judgment.
  • Easier to over-borrow because nothing specific is at stake.

Which should you choose?

  • Good to excellent credit: start with unsecured offers. If the rate is competitive, there is no need to risk an asset.
  • Fair or thin credit: a share-secured loan at a credit union can be cheap and builds credit history. See what credit score you need.
  • Bad credit: secured options or a co-signer are often the only affordable choices; avoid high-cost title and payday loans. Personal loans for bad credit covers the safer options.
  • Large amounts for home improvements: home equity products can make sense, but only if the payment is clearly affordable.

Frequently asked questions

Is a secured or unsecured loan better?

A secured loan is usually cheaper and easier to get; an unsecured loan keeps your assets out of the deal. If you qualify for a good unsecured rate, it is the lower-risk choice for you.

Do secured loans build credit?

Yes. Lenders report them to the credit bureaus like any loan, so on-time payments build your history. Share-secured loans are a common credit-building tool.

What can be used as collateral for a personal loan?

Savings accounts, CDs, vehicles and sometimes investment accounts or other valuables, depending on the lender.

What happens if I default on an unsecured loan?

Late fees and credit damage follow, then collections. The lender or a debt buyer may sue, and a court judgment can lead to wage garnishment or a bank levy under state law.

Can I get an unsecured loan with bad credit?

Sometimes, but usually at high rates. Compare the total cost with secured options and credit union loans before you sign.